Ultrasound Multimodality Examination Improves the Diagnostic Efficiency of Non-Mass-Like Breast Lesions

Objective This study is focused on ultrasound multimodality examination, which refers to the combined use of three ultrasound examination modalities, ultrasound (US), acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI) imaging, and contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS). The purpose of this study is to analyze the value of applying ultrasound multimodality examination in the differential diagnosis of benign and malignant breast non-mass-like lesions (NMLs).

Methods Cases of breast NMLs were analyzed retrospectively, and the nature of all the lesions was verified by pathological examination. Based on the gray-scale ultrasound image characteristics, the cases were classified into types Ⅰ to Ⅴ, and type Ⅰ and type Ⅱ were further classified into 4 subtypes, Ⅰa, Ⅰb, Ⅱa, and Ⅱb, according to whether there was also calcification, and the proportion of malignant cases in each subtype was statistically analyzed. Logistic regression models of US, US+ARFI, US+CEUS, and US+ARFI+CEUS for the diagnosis of malignant cases were established, ROC curves were drawn, the area under the curve (AUC) was calculated, and comparisons were made accordingly. The detection rate of malignant NMLs without calcification (atypical malignant NMLs) by the combination examination of US, ARFI, and CEUS was analyzed.

Results A total of 407 cases were included in the study. All subjects were female, aged 22 to 81 years, with the average age being (47.0±11.0) years. There were 220 benign cases and 187 malignant cases. Ranked from the highest to the lowest, the malignancy proportion of the different types was Ⅰb>Ⅱb>Ⅲ>Ⅴ>Ⅰa>Ⅱa>Ⅳ. The malignant proportion of the low echo area with calcification was significantly higher than that of the lesions without calcification. The AUC (95% confidence interval CI) for diagnosing malignant cases with the logistic regression models of US, US+ARFI, US+CEUS, and US+ARFI+CEUS were 0.895 (0.862-0.927), 0.908 (0.878-0.937), 0.921 (0.893-0.948), and 0.927 (0.902-0.952), respectively. Comparison of the AUC of the 4 regression models showed significant differences (P<0.001). The detection rate of US for NMLs without calcification was 80.7%. When US was used in combination with ARFI and CEUS, 86.4% of the malignant NMLs lesions without calcification could be detected if the lesion CEUS score was 4 or 5 points or if shear-wave velocity (SWV)≥4.28 m/s.

Conclusion Breast NMLs with calcification show high risks of malignancy, and a pathological examination is always recommended for a conclusive diagnosis. Ultrasound multimodality examination can improve the diagnostic accuracy of breast NML without calcification.